Click a year in the table below for an in-depth look into that season.
| Year | Division Champs | Conference Champs | Lakefront Bowl Champ | MVP | GMoY |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | Tucson (4) | Mason Bautch | |||
| 2024 | Boston Milwaukee (6) Los Angeles (5) |
Chicago Green Bay (3) |
Green Bay (2) | Ja'Marr Chase | Michael Bautch (3) |
| 2023 | Milwaukee (5) Northern Arizona (2) Philadelphia (2) |
Milwaukee (4) Northern Arizona (2) |
Milwaukee (2) | Christian McCaffrey (2) | Dan Schilts |
| 2022 | Cleveland (4) Los Angeles (4) Miami (4) |
Northern Arizona Green Bay (2) |
Green Bay | Austin Ekeler | Liz Bautch |
| 2021 | Brooklyn (4) Milwaukee (4) Los Angeles (3) |
Brooklyn (3) Los Angeles (2) |
Brooklyn (2) | Cooper Kupp | Cory Colvin (2) |
| 2020 | Cancelled | ||||
| 2019 | Chicago (2) Miami (3) Los Angeles (2) |
Brooklyn (2) Miami (3) |
Miami (3) | Christian McCaffrey | Richard Head |
| 2018 | Cedar Rapids Chicago |
Cedar Rapids Vegas (2) |
Vegas (2) | Saquon Barkley | Michael Arroyo |
| 2017 | Cleveland (3) Green Bay (3) Philadelphia |
Miami (2) Philadelphia |
Miami (2) | Todd Gurley | Bruce Coppersmith |
| 2016 | Cleveland (2) Miami (2) Northern Arizona |
Cleveland (2) Miami |
Miami | David Johnson | Cody Coppersmith |
| 2015 | Brooklyn (3) Milwaukee (3) Vegas |
Milwaukee (3) Vegas |
Vegas | Antonio Brown (2) | Michael Bautch (2) |
| 2014 | Cleveland Miami Green Bay (2) |
Cleveland Milwaukee (2) |
Milwaukee | Antonio Brown | Paris Reed |
| 2013 | Milwaukee (2) Brooklyn (2) Green Bay |
Brooklyn Milwaukee |
Brooklyn | LeSean McCoy | Cory Colvin |
| 2012 | Brooklyn Los Angeles Milwaukee |
Los Angeles Green Bay |
Los Angeles | Adrian Peterson | Michael Bautch |